Skip to main content Skip to navigation

Final Research Assignment: Prostitution in France

Download PDF

Paris has always been known as “the city of love” for many reasons; how beautiful and romantic the city is, and the amount of sex workers that are in the city. In France, many women work as sex workers because they get paid much more than what they would be getting paid for having a “real job”. That doesn’t make it okay for them to work like that though. Many women who are prostitutes are in dangerous conditions, not knowing what their nights are going to be like or whom they are going to be with. Many women continue to work regardless of the terrible conditions because they need to make a living somehow. Per the article, “it’s not against the law to take money for sex in France, the new legislation—passed on Wednesday by the National Assembly—makes almost everything connected with the trade, including paying the money illegal.” [1] This is supposed to cause less prostitutes in France, but no matter what there will always be women doing this kind of work. Most people believe women go into prostitution for their benefit and sexual desires but this is not true. Women and young girls get involved with prostitution because they need to find some substantial work. Prostitution has been relevant in society and culture, mainly focused on French culture, involving many young girls and older women. Women and young girls go into prostitution because they are born into poverty and can’t afford to go attend school, and need to find work to earn money for a way of living. These women are being forced into this labor because they need to feel significant and have a sense of worth in their lives. The book, Writing with a Vengeance, is an account of a young girl, Céleste, who goes through life and becomes a prostitute. Mossman, the author, writes, “in 1840 Céleste Vénard registered herself with the Parisian police as a prostitute in accordance with the regulations (Mossman, 6)”. [2] She was at a such a young and vulnerable age that she didn’t really know what she was doing. She needed to find a job and earn a living, and this was the only job she could find. Women are being forced into working in such a harsh way because they cannot afford to obtain a different job, since they aren’t qualified or they need more money than the job can provide. These women are being sexualized for money. Kilvington, Day, and Ward write, “the major problems of prostitution for the workers remain exploitation, stigma, abuse and criminalization.” [3] Women are performing this work in dangerous conditions that they shouldn’t have to endure.

Figure 1: A Prostitute in France Posing for Pictures

Prostitution in France stared way back, when many girls were being kicked out of their home due to various reasons, needing to find a job quickly that would support themselves and most times, their children or families. There have been many preconceptions about France and prostitution, being that women only do it for their sexual desires, but that is incorrect. Women get involved with it because they need to support themselves some way, and cannot get a job because they lack an education. Since prostitution arose in France, and other parts of the world, there have been many events, laws created or lacked, and different theatrical components that have influenced prostitution in many ways. Prostitution has continued today through these major events, making it become a long-kept idea that will never diminish. Prostitution was formed due to major events like, the creation of brothels, rise of diseases among prostitutes, the birth of the cabaret and the multiple wars, which all shaped it to a longer lasting idea today, that has gotten worse over time.

 Today, there are many women in France that go into prostitution because they cannot obtain a decent job since they aren’t qualified or they don’t have an education that can help them achieve a job. So, their last resort is prostitution. This happens from ages ranging from as young as 15 to as old as 40. Many women are struggling into finding work that can pay a decent amount and help them achieve a better life. In recent years, there hasn’t been much stop to prostitution in France. Many women work in brothels, private areas, or even in the public because those are only some of the places that they can go to perform these sexual acts without being criminalized. Brothels started to become regulated around the 1800’s, with many men and women engaging in them, both having different ideas entering into this place. Women are trying to earn a living by performing sexual acts in these regulated places, while men are going to brothels for social engagement. Governments in France knew that prostitution was a problem, but they also knew that they could never get rid of it completely. Since they couldn’t end the problem right away, they started to regulate brothels with the Morals Brigade. According to Rachel Fuchs, an author who wrote Gender and Poverty in the Nineteenth Century Europe, “the police in these countries attempted to regulate the pay and living conditions of prostitutes, licensing them to work in brothels or in certain areas of the cities (Fuchs, 193)”. [4] Everyone knew that prostitution was a job for many young, unsuccessful women, that they needed to regulate it somehow. They weren’t trying necessarily to get rid of it, but instead finding a way that would both benefit the social aspect of France and the young women who were selling themselves. This essentially didn’t end prostitution, but instead made it continue throughout time, leading to much worse events.

With so many women engaging in prostitution and men too, many diseases were going to be passed around from one person to another. With so many women working in the brothels, throughout the streets, and other areas, nothing was ever clean. Men didn’t care how clean these areas were, they were only there to have their satisfactions met. The police, or Morals Brigade, weren’t there to clean either. They were there to keep an eye out and make sure all prostitutes that were engaging in work, were registered with the police. There were so many germs flying around in these places that no one ever really cared to clean up after. Around 1850, many diseases were becoming aware among men and women. According to the Feminizing Venereal Disease, a book written by Mary Spongberg, she writes, “women were the main source of venereal “poison’ (Spongberg, 9)”. [5] These young girls and women couldn’t afford to see a doctor and get routine checkups. They had to rely on the police who “forced them to appear at dispensaries to have regular pelvic medical examinations for venereal disease (Fuchs, 193).” [4] If women didn’t show up to these appointments then they would be arrested right away and thrown into jail. No matter what, women couldn’t win. They were objectifying themselves by engaging in prostitution and weren’t given any rights. And then they were seen as objects because men didn’t care about them. All they needed was money, while men needed to satisfy their pleasures because they couldn’t receive these kinds of sexual acts from their wives. Women were putting their lives in danger, especially obtaining venereal disease or any other diseases that contributed to society. Since men didn’t care about them, they didn’t mind asking if they had any kind of disease. Women weren’t going to tell them either because then they couldn’t get paid. It was a cycle that kept going around and around, contributing to why women are still engaging in prostitution today. Getting a disease is not going to stop them from working, they will continue working while acquired with these diseases, because they have no other form of work. This continued throughout France and other parts of the world, with the creation of the cabaret and Moulin Rouge.

Throughout the next couple of years, after many diseases were being spread around, prostitution became more looked at as a theatrical idea. Now, in the 1870’s new ways of entertainment were being formed. Prostitution didn’t end, but started to become more as a way of life for many women. They started opening more theaters where men could go and watch women dance, and if they both enjoyed each other, women would go home with the men and get paid for sexual favors. This was a new form of entertainment in France.  Cabarets were theaters that included dances, shows, and much more. They were mainly focused on women who’d dance for men. These clubs would be for higher up men in society because they were a lot nicer than brothels. Brothels were for low-societal men who couldn’t afford much, but these women would work in the cabarets because they knew they’d get paid much more than working in the brothels. A paper written by Professor Holley, stated that “the cabaret reversed the growing pattern of bigger and bigger entertainment by focusing on intimacy and very specific artistic goals.” [6] These men would go to the cabarets to get away from their families and find a new form of intimacy. This ties in with the idea that women were still involving themselves in prostitution some way, making it a prominent idea today. The creation of cabarets didn’t end prostitution but made it easier for women to get involved. One cabaret that was

Figure 2: A Poster for the Moulin Rouge

most famous for women to get involved with was the Moulin Rouge. The Moulin Rouge was another cabaret that had many women dance, perform shows, and showed many different forms of entertainment. An artist that would paint many pictures of prostitutes and different dancers that went to the Moulin Rouge and find different women to paint. According to France in the Age of Les Miserable, “Lautrec also frequented the theater, the circus, Parisian brothels and often dance halls along with prostitutes, who mingled among the clientele in search of business.” [7] He would find women to look for and paint, while parading with other women around the cabaret. The Moulin Rouge affected many women throughout France, and men. It was a place that many women could find a job at and still get paid a ton of money by involving themselves in prostitution. The formation of these cabarets didn’t end prostitution, but again, made it more socially acceptable. These women were selling themselves for money, so that they could live and enjoy life.

From the 1870’s till the 1930’s not much was happening with prostitution in France. It was still going on, around France, but no one was finding a way to end it. Then, in the 1930’s Hitler rose to power and started World War II. Though, much before the war there were some laws that regulated prostitution. According to the book, written by Colin Jones, Prostitution and the Ruling Class in Eighteenth-Century Montpellier, the government imposed many measures to try and end prostitution. These measures were focused on the middle class, and didn’t really end prostitution. They only reduced it. First, they write, “a series of laws between 1684 and 1687 attempted to eradicate the problem of prostitutes following the army (Jones, 8).” [8] They wanted to diminish the chance of obtaining a disease from these “sex workers”. They didn’t care about these women, but instead wanted to do everything that they could to get rid of them. Throughout the war, prostitution was becoming more prominent around France. Many women were getting back into business because they had so many men coming around their country that they found “new work”. Once the United States got involved, that’s when prostitution sky rocketed. Many Americans were looking for prostitutes to help end their sexual desires. A book, The Price of Discretion, written by Mary Roberts talks about how the Americans went to France and needed to have their desires fulfilled before going into the war. She writes, “in September 1944, while leading the 29th Infantry Division across Brittany to liberate France, the American general Charles Gerhardt decided that his boys needed sex. So, he instructed his chief of staff to start a house of prostitution”. [9] These men all thought that they needed sex before freeing France, so they’re general got it for them. This was a huge success for the prostitutes because they were finding more work. The beginning of the war caused them to go into hiding because there was a war happening around them. They weren’t safe from all the men protruding their town, but instead waited until men came to free France. Prostitution was never going to end. No matter what, women would find somewhere and some way to sell themselves for money. They didn’t have an education so, they couldn’t find a real job, making prostitution their last resort. Prostitution continued throughout time, making it much worse today because so many women are still engaging in this type of work.

Before 1980, France had occurred many problems with prostitution and today, still does. In 1960, there was an article published in The New York times explaining the measures they are taking to prevent prostitution and have women obtain a “more normal life.” [10] The article was written for people who were paying for prostitution and, or prostitutes in general. The purpose of the article is to inform people who are paying for prostitution that the government and police are taking serious measures to end prostitution. The New York times writes, “broader powers have been given to the police to control hotels and bars frequented by prostitutes. Such establishments may now be closed for periods of three months to five years and the proprietor faces possible loss of his driver’s license and passport.” [10] Anybody found with a prostitute will face huge consequences. Prostitution today has become a large part of French culture because of its past and present events. Many women become a part of prostitution, like earlier stated, because they need to find some substantial form of work, without an education. Prostitution in the early 1800’s was dirty, filthy, and very unsafe. It is still dirty, filthy, and very unsafe today because women do not know what they are getting themselves into. Women are being forced into working in such a harsh way because they cannot afford to obtain a different job, since they aren’t qualified or they need more money than the job can provide. These women are being sexualized for money. The British Medical Journal, written in 1957, wrote about prostitution saying that “Lombroso regarded prostitution in women as the equivalent of crime in men.” [11] This is comparing men committing actual crimes, like burglary or arson, to women who are trying to make money to support themselves. This is unfair. There was also another newspaper article, written by the New York Times in 1975, talking about several prostitutes that are calling federation and fighting for what they want. A quote written in the newspaper from a prostitute reads, “As a result, some of us have been getting arrested for or five times a night. Usually that means a $40 fine, or several nights in jail. What is particularly intolerable, is that then they send us to prison, they take our children away from us.” [12] Women aren’t receiving care from France, but instead being objectified. They need to end prostitution all around the world and finally come up with a plan that will end it. Some measures were taken, according to CNN, “The French National Assembly outlawed the hiring of prostitutes while eliminating penalties for sex workers”. [13] Prostitution is finally going to be recognized in the favor of the women, instead of the men. This is a huge event that is happening in France today because so many women are forcing themselves into this work.

Figure 3: A Group of Prostitutes in France

Starting around the 1800’s, major events throughout time have affected what prostitution is like today. With the creation of brothels, many more young women entered this type of work. These brothels were filthy, thus leading to the rise of diseases. Many men and women didn’t know who had which disease because no one would tell whom and the police wouldn’t regulate it very well. Though, the Morals Brigade affected prostitution by restricting women to sign a registrar stating what they were engaging in and such. As the amount of people who obtained diseases rose, the creation of cabarets and the Moulin Rouge made prostitution a more socially accepted idea, which caused it to spread even more throughout the years. Though, after a couple of years’ prostitution was on the down low because not many things were happening around the world, but then the second world war began and caused prostitution to rise again. Ever since the war, prostitution has been on the rise and continues today. These events contributed to what prostitution is today, causing it to become a way of life for women that is unacceptable.

Endnotes:

[1] Dickey, C “France’s New Prostitution Law Targets Johns, Ignites National Debate” 5 December 2013 https://search.proquest.com/docview/1662703172?accoundtid=14902

(assessed 20 January 2017)

[2]: Mossman, Carol. Writing with a Vengeance. Canada: University of Toronto, 2009

[3]:Kilvington, Judith, Sophie Day, and Helen Ward. “Prostitution Policy in Europe: A Time of Change?” Feminist Review, no. 67 (2001): 78-93.

[4]: Fuchs, Rachel G. Gender and poverty in nineteenth-century Europe. Cambridge: Cambridge university press, 2005.

[5]: Spongberg, Mary. Feminizing venereal disease: the body of the prostitute in nineteenth-century medical discourse. Basingstoke: Macmillan Press, 1997.

[6]: Holley, Professor David. “A Historical and Musical Perspective of a Struggling Era.” 2010.

[7]: “France in the Age of Les Miserables.” Toulouse-Lautrec: Painting prostitution as it was. Accessed April 28, 2017. https://www.mtholyoke.edu/courses/rschwart/hist255-s01/courtesans/Toulouse-Lautrec-painting-prostitiution-as-it-was.htm.

[8]: Jones, Colin. “Prostitution and the Ruling Class in Eighteenth-Century Montpellier.” History Workshop, no. 6 (1978): 7-28. http://www.jstor.org/stable/4288189.

[9]: Mary Louise Roberts; The Price of Discretion: Prostitution, Venereal Disease, and the American Military in France, 1944–1946. Am Hist Rev 2010; 115 (4): 1002-1030. doi: 10.1086/ahr.115.4.1002

[10]: “Prostitution Curbs Posed in France” New York Times, November 28 1960 (Assessed February 6 2017) https://ntserver1.wsulibs.wsu.edu:6117/docview/115114525?accountid=14902

[11]: “Prostitution.” The British Medical Journal 2, no. 5041 (1957): 399-400. http://www.jstor.org/stable/25383562.

[12]: “FRENCH PROSTITUTES FORM A FEDERATION.” 1975.New York Times (1923-Current File), Jun 18, 23. https://ntserver1.wsulibs.wsu.edu:6117/docview/120383873?accountid=14902.

[13]: Yan, Holly. “France: Prostitution legal, paying for sex illegal.” CNN. April 07, 2016. Accessed April 28, 2017. http://www.cnn.com/2016/04/07/europe/france-prostitution/

Illustration Endnotes:

Figure 1: Edmonds, Mandee. “HIGHLY RATED FRENCH PROSTITUTE, ALICE MAROT ON A WINDOW SILL IN PARIS, FRANCE.” Pinterest. April 27, 2011. Accessed April 28, 2017. https://www.pinterest.com/pin/132152570289115315/.

Figure 2: Myers, Author: Nicole. “The Lure of Montmartre, 1880–1900 | Essay | Heilbrunn Timeline of Art History | The Metropolitan Museum of Art.” The Met’s Heilbrunn Timeline of Art History. Accessed April 28, 2017. http://www.metmuseum.org/toah/hd/mont/hd_mont.htm.

Figure 3: Wallace, Tamra. “Paris Circa 1900’s.” Pinterest. October 31, 2012. Accessed April 28, 2017. https://www.pinterest.com/pin/419749627739426030/.

DRA #4: Prostitution in France

Download PDF

DRA #4

Hook: Today, there are many women in France that go into prostitution because they cannot obtain a decent job because they aren’t qualified or they don’t have an education that can help them achieve a job. So, there last resort is prostitution. This happens from ages ranging from as young as 15 to as old as 40. Many women are struggling into finding work that can pay a decent amount and help them achieve a better life. In recent years, there hasn’t been much stop to prostitution in France. Many women work in brothels, private areas, or even in the public because those are only some of the places that they can go to perform these sexual acts without being criminalized. Women are being forced into working in such a harsh way because they cannot afford to obtain a different job, since they aren’t qualified or they need more money than the job can provide. These women are being sexualized for money. Kilvington, Day, and Ward write, “the major problems of prostitution for the workers remain exploitation, stigma, abuse and criminalization.” [5] Women are performing this work in dangerous conditions that they shouldn’t have to endure.

Thesis (Paragraph #2): The rise of prostitution among young women in France is due to the lack of laws regulating the practice and, the rise of inequality among women from men. There have been many preconceptions about France and prostitution that women only do it for their sexual desires, but that is incorrect. Women get involved with it because they need to support themselves some way, and cannot get a job because they lack the education. There has also been a lack of laws regarding prostitution and hasn’t been stopped. These women are enduring such hard conditions, that one would think to try to stop it permanently.

Paragraph #3: Preconceptions about France and prostitution

Paris has always been known as “the city of love” for many reasons; how beautiful and romantic the city is, and the amount of sex workers that are in the city. In France, many women work as sex workers because they get paid much more than what they would be getting paid for having a “real job”. That doesn’t make it okay for them to work like that though. Many women who are prostitutes are in dangerous conditions, not knowing what their nights are going to be like or whom they are going to be with. Many women continue to work regardless of the terrible conditions because they need to make a living somehow. Per the article, “it’s not against the law to take money for sex in France, the new legislation—passed on Wednesday by the National Assembly—makes almost everything connected with the trade, including paying the money illegal.” [1] This is supposed to cause less prostitutes in France, but no matter what there will always be women doing this kind of work. Most people believe women go into prostitution for their benefit and sexual desires but this is not true. Women and young girls get involved with prostitution because they need to find some substantial work.

Paragraph #4: How women get involved into prostitution

Prostitution has been relevant in society and culture, mainly focused on French culture, involving many young girls and older women. Women and young girls go into prostitution because they are born into poverty and can’t afford to go attend school, and need to find work to earn money for a way of living. These women are being forced into this labor because they need to feel significant and have a sense of worth in their lives. The book, Writing with a Vengeance, is an account of a young girl, Céleste, who goes through life and becomes a prostitute. Mossman, the author, writes, “in 1840 Céleste Vénard registered herself with the Parisian police as a prostitute in accordance with the regulations.” [3] She was at a such a young and vulnerable age that she didn’t really know what she was doing. She needed to find some form of work that allowed her to work at a young age and earn some sort of living. Most of these women that are going into prostitution are from families or environments that are hurting them emotionally and physically. Among these women, most of them are being raped or beaten from someone in their family. Céleste didn’t have a father figure in her life, except her “mother’s lover” [3], Vincent, which “attempted seduction and rape.” [3] Vincent tried to force Céleste to have sex with him because she was going into prostitution and that she wanted it. Yes, that’s her way of living and finding money but it is not okay to force it out of her and rape her. These girls are coming from some sort of broken relationship that they then go and find some way to heal it. This was another reason that many young women fall into prostitution. First, money, and second, a torn relationship. Céleste didn’t necessarily have the best relationship with her mom, in fact it was terrible. Mossman writes, “…consented to give the written parental permission required for minors.” [3] After her mom gave her consent, their relationship was broken. Céleste went on and became a full-time prostitute. These women are enduring horrible conditions because they have no other way of finding a job because they lack the proper education. These women are also coming from harsh conditions before they even go into work. They’re coming from broken families that lead them to fend for themselves and try to live a new life. Those are the main reasons why prostitution started to become more relevant in society and, continue today.

Paragraph #5: Laws regarding prostitution

Before 1980, France had many problems with prostitution and today, still does. In 1960, there was an article published in The New York times explaining the measures they are taking to prevent prostitution and have women obtain a “more normal life.” [2] The article was written for people who were paying for prostitution and, or prostitutes in general. The purpose of the article is to inform people who are paying for prostitution that the government and police are taking serious measures to end prostitution. The New York times writes, “broader powers have been given to the police to control hotels and bars frequented by prostitutes. Such establishments may now be closed for periods of three months to five years and the proprietor faces possible loss of his driver’s license and passport.” [2] Anybody found with a prostitute will face huge consequences. The article was written on November 28, 1960 and read after it was printed. The author of the article is probably American since the article is from the New York Times. I think he may have a biased opinion on the situation happening in France because he isn’t in the country experiencing what is happening. The article is just meant to inform people on the consequences and give an insight on what is going on in other countries. One unspoken assumption the article contains is that there seems to be a lot of prostitution in France and that people haven’t been doing anything about it. In France, prostitution was so relevant that they weren’t sure what to do. So many women and young girls were getting involved in it, that they couldn’t stop mass movements of it. Soon enough, they presented laws that prohibited it, and tried to end prostitution. According to the book, Prostitution and the Ruling Class in Eighteenth-Century Montpellier, the government imposed many measures to try and end prostitution. These measures were focused on the middle class, and didn’t really end prostitution. They only reduced it. First, they write, “a series of laws between 1684 and 1687 attempted to eradicate the problem of prostitutes following the army.” [7] They wanted to diminish the chance of obtaining a disease from these “sex workers”. They didn’t care about these women, but instead wanted to do everything that they could to get rid of them. This also relates to the idea that men were treated better than women during these times, and still are. They continued to write laws that tried to end prostitution, they write, “the second aspect of government measures in the 1680’s was concerned with the honour of families.” [7] Again, the government did not care about the women, but the face of their families. They wanted everyone’s family to look great and act like they didn’t do anything wrong. They wanted the perfect family. These women who are involved in prostitution obviously didn’t care about what their families though. They needed to find a way to make money fast, and carry on with their lives. These laws did not end prostitution because it is still occurring today in many places around the world, especially in France.

Paragraph #6: Inequality among men and women with crime and prostitution, and how prostitutes are being treated

Today, many people define standards for men and women. Women are expected to act like a charming lady while men are to show how masculine and tough they are. This is unacceptable. Women, are also treated way differently than men. Men are treated like kings, always in charge and controlling everything around them. This is a prominent issue in prostitution today. These women don’t know where they’re going when they are “picked up” and don’t know anything about these men. They have a sense of fear in them, not knowing what their nights are going to be like. The British Medical Journal, written in 1957, wrote about prostitution saying that “Lombroso regarded prostitution in women as the equivalent of crime in men.” [8] This is comparing men committing actual crimes, like burglary or arson, to women who are trying to make money to support themselves. This is unfair. There was also another newspaper article, written by the New York Times in 1975, talking about several prostitutes that are calling federation and fighting for what they want. A quote written in the newspaper from a prostitute reads, “As a result, some of us have been getting arrested for or five times a night. Usually that means a $40 fine, or several nights in jail. What is particularly intolerable, is that then they send us to prison, they take our children away from us.” [9] The authorities do not see these women as women, they instead see them as sex objects because they do not believe that they are real people. This is wrong, they have lives, children and families that they need to support, but instead are being treated wrongly. When they are taken away for multiple nights, it puts a huge damper on them. A few nights can mean losing hundreds or thousands of dollars for them. This is all unacceptable. These women aren’t being treated fairly among their male race, and are also not being treated right by the authorities.

Paragraph #7: What’s happening today with prostitution

Conclusion: How to end prostitution and why it’s important in society

[1] Dickey, C “France’s New Prostitution Law Targets Johns, Ignites National Debate” 5 December 2013 https://search.proquest.com/docview/1662703172?accoundtid=14902

[2] “Prostitution Curbs Posed in France” New York Times, November 28 1960 (Assessed February 6 2017) https://ntserver1.wsulibs.wsu.edu:6117/docview/115114525?accountid=14902

[3]: Mossman, Carol. Writing with a Vengeance. Canada: University of Toronto, 2009

[4]: Gaissad, Laurent. “From Nightlife Conventions to Daytime Hidden Agendas: Dynamics of Urban Sexual Territories in the South of France.” The Journal of Sex Research 42, no. 1 (2005): 20-27.

[5]:Kilvington, Judith, Sophie Day, and Helen Ward. “Prostitution Policy in Europe: A Time of Change?” Feminist Review, no. 67 (2001): 78-93.

[7] Jones, Colin. “Prostitution and the Ruling Class in Eighteenth-Century Montpellier.” History Workshop, no. 6 (1978): 7-28. http://www.jstor.org/stable/4288189.

[8] “Prostitution.” The British Medical Journal 2, no. 5041 (1957): 399-400. http://www.jstor.org/stable/25383562.

[9] “FRENCH PROSTITUTES FORM A FEDERATION.” 1975.New York Times (1923-Current File), Jun 18, 23. https://ntserver1.wsulibs.wsu.edu:6117/docview/120383873?accountid=14902.

Prostitution in France: DRA #1,2, and 3

Download PDF

Spring 2017-Samantha Krebs

History 105-Matthew Unangst

Digital Research Assignment #1

France’s New Prostitution Law Targets Johns, Ignites National Debate

Paris has always been known as “the city of love” for many reasons; how beautiful and romantic the city is, and the amount of sex workers that are in the city. In France, many women work as sex workers because they get paid much more than what they would be getting paid for having a “real job”. That doesn’t make it okay for them to work like that though. Many women who are prostitutes are in dangerous conditions, not knowing what their nights are going to be like or whom they are going to be with. Many women continue to work regardless of the terrible conditions because they need to make a living somehow. Per the article, “it’s not against the law to take money for sex in France, the new legislation—passed on Wednesday by the National Assembly—makes almost everything connected with the trade, including paying the money illegal.” [1] This is supposed to cause less prostitutes in France, but no matter what there will always be women doing this kind of work.

[1] Dickey, C “France’s New Prostitution Law Targets Johns, Ignites National Debate” 5 December 2013 https://search.proquest.com/docview/1662703172?accoundtid=14902

(assessed 20 January 2017)

Geographic Focus: Paris, France-France in general

Search Terms: prostitutes*, women*, Paris, France

The Roots of Inequality: This relates to the roots of inequality because women are doing obscene work for money in conditions that are not right or justified.

DRA #2

Prostitution Curbs Imposed in France

Before 1980, France had many problems with prostitution and today, still does. In 1960 there was an article published in The New York times explaining the measures they are taking to prevent prostitution and have women obtain a “more normal life.” [2] The article was written for people who were paying for prostitution and, or prostitutes in general. The purpose of the article is to inform people who are paying for prostitution that the government and police are taking serious measures to end prostitution. The New York times writes, “broader powers have been given to the police to control hotels and bars frequented by prostitutes. Such establishments may now be closed for periods of three months to five years and the proprietor faces possible loss of his driver’s license and passport.” [2] Anybody found with a prostitute will face huge consequences. The article was written on November 28, 1960 and read after it was printed. The author of the article is probably American since the article is from the New York Times. I think he may have a biased opinion on the situation happening in France because he isn’t in the country experiencing what is happening. The article is just meant to inform people on the consequences and give an insight on what is going on in other countries. One unspoken assumption the article contains is that there seems to be a lot of prostitution in France and that people haven’t been doing anything about it.

[2] “Prostitution Curbs Posed in France” New York Times, November 28 1960 (Assessed February 6 2017) https://ntserver1.wsulibs.wsu.edu:6117/docview/115114525?accountid=14902

Historical Questions

Question A: Were there any laws that ended prostitution or did they enforce any laws that would prevent it?

Question B: How did prostitution effect the economy?

DRA #3

Hook: Today, there are many women in France that go into prostitution because they cannot obtain a decent job because they aren’t qualified or they don’t have an education that can help them achieve a job. So, there last resort is prostitution. This happens from ages ranging from as young as 15 to as old as 40. Many women are struggling into finding work that can pay a decent amount and help them achieve a better life. In recent years, there hasn’t been much stop to prostitution in France. Many women work in brothels, private areas, or even in the public because those are only some of the places that they can go to perform these sexual acts without being criminalized. Women are being forced into working in such a harsh way because they cannot afford to obtain a different job, since they aren’t qualified or they need more money than the job can provide. These women are being sexualized for money. Kilvington, Day, and Ward write, “the major problems of prostitution for the workers remain exploitation, stigma, abuse and criminalization.” [5] Women are performing this work in dangerous conditions that they shouldn’t have to endure.

Thesis Statement: The rise of prostitution among young women in France is due to the lack of laws regulating the practice and, the rise of inequality among women from men.

Paragraph #3: Analyze and talk about how women get into prostitution and what kinds of things they do and get paid for. [5]

Paragraph #4: Talk about the rise of prostitution in the last century and talk about how it’s affecting the economy and “idea” of France. [3], [4]

Paragraph #5: Analyze the laws regarding prostitution in France and what kinds of places are legal and illegal for prostitution. [4]

Paragraph #6: Compare prostitution in France and other places in Europe. In 1911, laws were introduced in the Netherlands. They write, “National legislation regarding prostitution in the Netherlands, like most European countries, has been abolitionist, and anyone involved in the organization of, or living off, prostitution has been criminalized.” [5] They are trying to find everyone who is involved in prostitution and turn them into a criminal, it seems. They aren’t trying to help these women that are involved in it, but rather find the “criminal” and put them away. They never truly acknowledge the harsh obstacles that these women have been trying to overcome. [5]

Conclusion: How it relates to the world today and what kinds of prostitutions laws are being regulated or created in France

New Historical Research Question: How did the rise of poverty among women affect them going into the prostitution business?

Database used: JSTOR and Search It

Search Terms: France, prostitut*, wom?n

Era: 1900s-Today

Books:

[3]: Mossman, Carol. Writing with a Vengeance. Canada: University of Toronto, 2009

Journals:

[4]: Gaissad, Laurent. “From Nightlife Conventions to Daytime Hidden Agendas: Dynamics of Urban Sexual Territories in the South of France.” The Journal of Sex Research 42, no. 1 (2005): 20-27.

[5]:Kilvington, Judith, Sophie Day, and Helen Ward. “Prostitution Policy in Europe: A Time of Change?” Feminist Review, no. 67 (2001): 78-93.

DRA #4

Hook: Today, there are many women in France that go into prostitution because they cannot obtain a decent job because they aren’t qualified or they don’t have an education that can help them achieve a job. So, there last resort is prostitution. This happens from ages ranging from as young as 15 to as old as 40. Many women are struggling into finding work that can pay a decent amount and help them achieve a better life. In recent years, there hasn’t been much stop to prostitution in France. Many women work in brothels, private areas, or even in the public because those are only some of the places that they can go to perform these sexual acts without being criminalized. Women are being forced into working in such a harsh way because they cannot afford to obtain a different job, since they aren’t qualified or they need more money than the job can provide. These women are being sexualized for money. Kilvington, Day, and Ward write, “the major problems of prostitution for the workers remain exploitation, stigma, abuse and criminalization.” [5] Women are performing this work in dangerous conditions that they shouldn’t have to endure.

 

Thesis (Paragraph #2): The rise of prostitution among young women in France is due to the lack of laws regulating the practice and, the rise of inequality among women from men. There have been many preconceptions about France and prostitution that women only do it for their sexual desires, but that is incorrect. Women get involved with it because they need to support themselves some way, and cannot get a job because they lack the education. There has also been a lack of laws regarding prostitution and hasn’t been stopped. These women are enduring such hard conditions, that one would think to try to stop it permanently.

 

Paragraph #3: Preconceptions about France and prostitution

Paris has always been known as “the city of love” for many reasons; how beautiful and romantic the city is, and the amount of sex workers that are in the city. In France, many women work as sex workers because they get paid much more than what they would be getting paid for having a “real job”. That doesn’t make it okay for them to work like that though. Many women who are prostitutes are in dangerous conditions, not knowing what their nights are going to be like or whom they are going to be with. Many women continue to work regardless of the terrible conditions because they need to make a living somehow. Per the article, “it’s not against the law to take money for sex in France, the new legislation—passed on Wednesday by the National Assembly—makes almost everything connected with the trade, including paying the money illegal.” [1] This is supposed to cause less prostitutes in France, but no matter what there will always be women doing this kind of work. Most people believe women go into prostitution for their benefit and sexual desires but this is not true. Women and young girls get involved with prostitution because they need to find some substantial work.

 

Paragraph #4: How women get involved into prostitution

Prostitution has been relevant in society and culture, mainly focused on French culture, involving many young girls and older women. Women and young girls go into prostitution because they are born into poverty and can’t afford to go attend school, and need to find work to earn money for a way of living. These women are being forced into this labor because they need to feel significant and have a sense of worth in their lives. The book, Writing with a Vengeance, is an account of a young girl, Céleste, who goes through life and becomes a prostitute. Mossman, the author, writes, “in 1840 Céleste Vénard registered herself with the Parisian police as a prostitute in accordance with the regulations.” [3] She was at a such a young and vulnerable age that she didn’t really know what she was doing. She needed to find some form of work that allowed her to work at a young age and earn some sort of living. Most of these women that are going into prostitution are from families or environments that are hurting them emotionally and physically. Among these women, most of them are being raped or beaten from someone in their family. Céleste didn’t have a father figure in her life, except her “mother’s lover” [3], Vincent, which “attempted seduction and rape.” [3] Vincent tried to force Céleste to have sex with him because she was going into prostitution and that she wanted it. Yes, that’s her way of living and finding money but it is not okay to force it out of her and rape her. These girls are coming from some sort of broken relationship that they then go and find some way to heal it. This was another reason that many young women fall into prostitution. First, money, and second, a torn relationship. Céleste didn’t necessarily have the best relationship with her mom, in fact it was terrible. Mossman writes, “…consented to give the written parental permission required for minors.” [3] After her mom gave her consent, their relationship was broken. Céleste went on and became a full-time prostitute. These women are enduring horrible conditions because they have no other way of finding a job because they lack the proper education. These women are also coming from harsh conditions before they even go into work. They’re coming from broken families that lead them to fend for themselves and try to live a new life. Those are the main reasons why prostitution started to become more relevant in society and, continue today.

 

Paragraph #5: Laws regarding prostitution

Before 1980, France had many problems with prostitution and today, still does. In 1960, there was an article published in The New York times explaining the measures they are taking to prevent prostitution and have women obtain a “more normal life.” [2] The article was written for people who were paying for prostitution and, or prostitutes in general. The purpose of the article is to inform people who are paying for prostitution that the government and police are taking serious measures to end prostitution. The New York times writes, “broader powers have been given to the police to control hotels and bars frequented by prostitutes. Such establishments may now be closed for periods of three months to five years and the proprietor faces possible loss of his driver’s license and passport.” [2] Anybody found with a prostitute will face huge consequences. The article was written on November 28, 1960 and read after it was printed. The author of the article is probably American since the article is from the New York Times. I think he may have a biased opinion on the situation happening in France because he isn’t in the country experiencing what is happening. The article is just meant to inform people on the consequences and give an insight on what is going on in other countries. One unspoken assumption the article contains is that there seems to be a lot of prostitution in France and that people haven’t been doing anything about it. In France, prostitution was so relevant that they weren’t sure what to do. So many women and young girls were getting involved in it, that they couldn’t stop mass movements of it. Soon enough, they presented laws that prohibited it, and tried to end prostitution. According to the book, Prostitution and the Ruling Class in Eighteenth-Century Montpellier, the government imposed many measures to try and end prostitution. These measures were focused on the middle class, and didn’t really end prostitution. They only reduced it. First, they write, “a series of laws between 1684 and 1687 attempted to eradicate the problem of prostitutes following the army.” [7] They wanted to diminish the chance of obtaining a disease from these “sex workers”. They didn’t care about these women, but instead wanted to do everything that they could to get rid of them. This also relates to the idea that men were treated better than women during these times, and still are. They continued to write laws that tried to end prostitution, they write, “the second aspect of government measures in the 1680’s was concerned with the honour of families.” [7] Again, the government did not care about the women, but the face of their families. They wanted everyone’s family to look great and act like they didn’t do anything wrong. They wanted the perfect family. These women who are involved in prostitution obviously didn’t care about what their families though. They needed to find a way to make money fast, and carry on with their lives. These laws did not end prostitution because it is still occurring today in many places around the world, especially in France.

 

Paragraph #6: Inequality among men and women with crime and prostitution, and how prostitutes are being treated  

Today, many people define standards for men and women. Women are expected to act like a charming lady while men are to show how masculine and tough they are. This is unacceptable. Women, are also treated way differently than men. Men are treated like kings, always in charge and controlling everything around them. This is a prominent issue in prostitution today. These women don’t know where they’re going when they are “picked up” and don’t know anything about these men. They have a sense of fear in them, not knowing what their nights are going to be like. The British Medical Journal, written in 1957, wrote about prostitution saying that “Lombroso regarded prostitution in women as the equivalent of crime in men.” [8] This is comparing men committing actual crimes, like burglary or arson, to women who are trying to make money to support themselves. This is unfair. There was also another newspaper article, written by the New York Times in 1975, talking about several prostitutes that are calling federation and fighting for what they want. A quote written in the newspaper from a prostitute reads, “As a result, some of us have been getting arrested for or five times a night. Usually that means a $40 fine, or several nights in jail. What is particularly intolerable, is that then they send us to prison, they take our children away from us.” [9] The authorities do not see these women as women, they instead see them as sex objects because they do not believe that they are real people. This is wrong, they have lives, children and families that they need to support, but instead are being treated wrongly. When they are taken away for multiple nights, it puts a huge damper on them. A few nights can mean losing hundreds or thousands of dollars for them. This is all unacceptable. These women aren’t being treated fairly among their male race, and are also not being treated right by the authorities.

 

Paragraph #7: What’s happening today with prostitution

Conclusion: How to end prostitution and why it’s important in society

 

[1] Dickey, C “France’s New Prostitution Law Targets Johns, Ignites National Debate” 5 December 2013 https://search.proquest.com/docview/1662703172?accoundtid=14902

[2] “Prostitution Curbs Posed in France” New York Times, November 28 1960 (Assessed February 6 2017) https://ntserver1.wsulibs.wsu.edu:6117/docview/115114525?accountid=14902

[3]: Mossman, Carol. Writing with a Vengeance. Canada: University of Toronto, 2009

[4]: Gaissad, Laurent. “From Nightlife Conventions to Daytime Hidden Agendas: Dynamics of Urban Sexual Territories in the South of France.” The Journal of Sex Research 42, no. 1 (2005): 20-27.

[5]:Kilvington, Judith, Sophie Day, and Helen Ward. “Prostitution Policy in Europe: A Time of Change?” Feminist Review, no. 67 (2001): 78-93.

[7] Jones, Colin. “Prostitution and the Ruling Class in Eighteenth-Century Montpellier.” History Workshop, no. 6 (1978): 7-28. http://www.jstor.org/stable/4288189.

[8] “Prostitution.” The British Medical Journal 2, no. 5041 (1957): 399-400. http://www.jstor.org/stable/25383562.

[9] “FRENCH PROSTITUTES FORM A FEDERATION.” 1975.New York Times (1923-Current File), Jun 18, 23. https://ntserver1.wsulibs.wsu.edu:6117/docview/120383873?accountid=14902.